GeoCities.us GeoCities.us » BourbonStreet » Levee Get your FREE home page!

Coffee cup THE PO-BOY PILGRIM
One man. Every po-boy shop in New Orleans. Rated on Bread, Filling and Mess.
Andre Fontenot, eating since 1997, still hungry
Fish

Every city has a sandwich. Philadelphia has that cheesesteak thing. Chicago's got the Italian beef. New Orleans has the po-boy, and I have made it my life's work, or at least my lunch's work, to eat one at every shop, corner grocery, gas station and seafood counter in Orleans Parish and the ones in Jefferson Parish that are close enough to count. My name is Andre, I'm 34, I work for the city (don't ask), and my lunch hour is an hour and fifteen minutes if nobody's watching.

The Pilgrimage started in February of 1997 when my cousin claimed the best roast beef po-boy in the city was at a place I'd never heard of in Gentilly, and I said no it's not, and it turned out neither of us could say for sure because neither of us had eaten at enough places. That seemed like a problem a man could fix. Two and a half years later the count is at 61 shops in 1999 alone and 140-something overall, my cholesterol is a closely guarded secret, and my cousin was wrong. (He was close, though. See Gentilly, below.)

Everything here is my own opinion, eaten on my own dime. No shop knows I'm coming. No shop knows who I am. Most of them are too busy to care.


Where It Came From | How to Order | Debris, Explained | The Rating Scale | 1999 Reviews | Fried Shrimp Rankings | The Count

WHERE IT CAME FROM (THE STORY EVERYBODY TELLS)

Here's the story you'll hear from anybody in this town over the age of fifty, and I've got no reason to doubt it. In 1929 the streetcar workers of New Orleans went on strike. Two brothers named Bennie and Clovis Martin, who had been streetcar conductors themselves before they opened a coffee stand and restaurant, said they'd feed any striking man who came by, free, for as long as the strike lasted. When one of the strikers walked in the door, somebody in the kitchen would holler, "Here comes another poor boy!" And the sandwich they fed him, a big cheap one on a long loaf of French bread, took the name. Poor boy, po' boy, po-boy. Spell it how you like. I spell it with the hyphen because that's how the sign at my first shop spelled it and I'm loyal.

Whether every detail of that is gospel I can't tell you, but the Martin brothers were real, the strike was real, and the bread was real, and the bread is the whole thing. New Orleans French bread is not French bread from anywhere else: it's got a thin, crackly crust that shatters when you bite it and an inside that's mostly air. It goes stale in about six hours, which is why the good shops get it delivered every morning and why a po-boy from a shop that uses yesterday's bread is a crime against the city. I'll say it again below because it's the most important thing on this page: the bread is the whole thing.

HOW TO ORDER (SO THEY DON'T KNOW YOU'RE FROM OUT OF TOWN)
  • "Dressed." The big one. A dressed po-boy comes with lettuce, tomato, pickles and mayonnaise. If you don't want that, you say "undressed" or "nothing on it." If you want some of it, you say "dressed, no pickles" or whatever. Do not say "with everything." Everything is called dressed. This is the whole test.
  • Sizes. Most shops sell by the length of the loaf. A "shorty" or half is six inches or so, a regular is a foot, and some places will sell you a whole loaf, which is a family event. Order the half. You can always get another half.
  • The classics. Roast beef (slow-cooked, sliced or shredded, soaked in its own gravy; see debris, below). Fried shrimp and fried oyster (the seafood ones; "half and half" gets you both on one loaf). Hot sausage (a spicy patty, not a link, most places). Ham and turkey for the timid. Catfish, soft-shell crab in season, and French fry po-boys, which is exactly what it sounds like, with gravy, for a dollar and a half, and don't knock it.
  • Hot sauce is on the table. Use it. Ketchup is also on the table; that's between you and your God.
  • Get it to go if the line's long, but eat it in the car in the parking lot. The bread does not survive the ride home.
DEBRIS, EXPLAINED

People from out of town see "roast beef debris" on a menu board and think somebody made a mistake. Nobody made a mistake. When you cook a big roast of beef for hours in a pot until it's falling apart, little pieces fall off into the gravy. Those little bits of beef swimming around in the drippings at the bottom of the pot, that's debris (say it the French way, DAY-bree, and if you say DEB-ris they'll know). It's the best part. A proper roast beef po-boy has sliced beef on it and then a ladle of gravy full of debris poured over the top, and a proper roast beef debris po-boy is just the debris, and either way you're going to need both hands and the whole stack of napkins, which brings me to the scale.

THE RATING SCALE

Every po-boy gets three scores, one to five each, for a possible 15.

BREADIs it fresh today? Does the crust crackle? Is the inside light? Did they toast it a little? Five is a loaf that showers your shirt with crust. One is a hoagie roll from a bag, and I have walked out.
FILLINGIs there enough of it? Is it good? Is the shrimp fried to order or sitting under a lamp? Is the roast beef falling apart the way it should? Five is a sandwich you can't close. One is a sandwich you can see through.
MESSHow many napkins, and did you need to change your shirt? Higher is better. A roast beef that doesn't drip is a roast beef that's dry. Five is a sandwich you have to lean over the table to eat. One is a sandwich you could eat in a car with white seats. (A fried shrimp can't really score higher than a 3 here, and I've adjusted my expectations.)
SELECTED 1999 REVIEWS New

I can't put all 61 up here or this page would take an hour to load on my modem, so here are the ones people ask about, by neighborhood. The full notebook is in the glove compartment of my truck, and if you e-mail me about a specific shop I'll look it up.

ShopWhat I hadB / F / MVerdict
Tee-Roy's Sandwich Shop
Mid-City
Roast beef, dressed5 / 5 / 5
15
The only perfect score of 1999. Bread delivered while I was standing in line. Gravy down to the elbow. Six napkins and I gave up and used the sleeve. There are nine stools and a lady who calls everybody "baby." This is the one, cousin. I'm sorry.
Miss Dot's Grocery
Bywater
Hot sausage, dressed4 / 5 / 4
13
A corner grocery with a counter in back, which is where a lot of the good ones hide. Patty is hand-formed and hotter than I expected in the best way. Bread was a hair soft, could've used the toaster. Buy a cold drink out of the cooler; it's the polite thing.
Gentilly Seafood & Deli
Gentilly
Roast beef debris4 / 5 / 5
14
My cousin's place. He wasn't wrong, just not right. Debris is deep, dark and plentiful; bread was very good but had been sitting an hour. If you go before 11:30 this might be a 15. I'll be back to check. Repeatedly.
Pelican Po-Boys
Uptown, Magazine Street
Fried shrimp, dressed5 / 5 / 3
13
Best fried shrimp of the year (see rankings below). Small shrimp, which is correct, fried to order in a batter that stays crisp under the mayo. Line out the door at noon. Worth it.
Duplantier's
Irish Channel
Fried oyster4 / 4 / 3
11
Solid oyster loaf, fat oysters, a little heavy on the cornmeal. Old-time place, older regulars, cash only, closed by 2. Go for the oysters, stay for the arguments about the Saints.
Two Sisters Sandwich Shop
Seventh Ward
Hot sausage with cheese5 / 4 / 4
13
Only sisters I've met who agree on everything, and the thing they agree on is the bread. Perfect crust. Sausage was a little thin on the shorty. Get the regular.
Algiers Point Grocery
Algiers
Roast beef, dressed3 / 4 / 5
12
Took the ferry for this one, which is the right way to get a po-boy on the West Bank. The gravy is spectacular and the bread was not up to it; it dissolved. Eat it fast. I did.
Bayou Road Deli
Treme / Esplanade Ridge
French fry po-boy with gravy4 / 3 / 5
12
A dollar seventy-five. Fries, gravy, dressed, on good bread. This is what the sandwich was invented for. I ate it on the curb like a poor boy and felt right with the world.
Lakeview Sandwich Stop
Lakeview
Turkey, dressed3 / 2 / 1
6
Ordered turkey because they were out of roast beef at 12:15, which tells you something. Sliced deli turkey, cold, on bread that had been in a bag. Clean. Neat. Wrong. I'm being kind with the 6.
Broadmoor Corner Store
Broadmoor
Half shrimp / half oyster4 / 4 / 3
11
Good honest seafood loaf from a place with a lottery machine and a cat. Both halves fried to order. The cat is not for sale, I asked.
Guidry's on the Avenue
Carrollton
Roast beef, dressed5 / 4 / 4
13
Very close to the top. Bread flawless, gravy a shade thin. If Tee-Roy's is closed (Sundays), this is where I go. Also the best sweet tea on the list, for what that's worth.
Metairie Road Po-Boys
Old Metairie (Jefferson Parish, but I'm counting it)
Hot sausage, dressed4 / 4 / 4
12
Good all around, nothing to complain about, nothing to write home about, which I realize is exactly what I'm doing.
THE 1999 FRIED SHRIMP RANKINGS

Roast beef is the king but fried shrimp is what people ask me about most, especially in the summer. Rules for a great one: small-to-medium Gulf shrimp (big ones are showing off and they don't fit), fried to order in a light crisp coating, enough of them that they fall out when you pick it up, and bread that's been given a minute in the toaster so the mayo doesn't sog it. Out of the 22 fried shrimp po-boys I ate in 1999, the top five:

  1. Pelican Po-Boys (Uptown). Crisp under the mayo. I've thought about this for weeks.
  2. Broadmoor Corner Store (Broadmoor). The cat gets no credit.
  3. Gentilly Seafood & Deli (Gentilly). Same people who do the debris. They can fry, too.
  4. Duplantier's (Irish Channel). Better at oysters, still very good at shrimp.
  5. A gas station on Chef Menteur Highway whose name I did not write down and which I have been unable to find again. If you know it, e-mail me. I'm serious. This is keeping me up nights.
THE COUNT
Shops visited, 1999 (through Sept. 24):61
Shops visited since Feb. 1997:143
Perfect 15s, all time:3
Shirts ruined:4 (that I'll admit to)
Shops left on the list:? (every time I cross one off, somebody tells me about two more)

Goal for the year is 75. Goal for life is all of them. If you've got a shop you think I've missed, especially the kind with a counter in the back of a grocery and a hand-lettered sign, tell me. Put the neighborhood in the subject line. I keep the e-mails in the notebook.


Other folks eating and dancing around here: Miss Odette's Creole Kitchen (she'll tell you how to make the roast beef at home; I'd rather buy it) · Second-Line Sundays (Charmaine's page; follow a parade and you'll walk past half the shops on my list) · The Crescent City Stompers · The Blues Harmonica Page · Small-Town Diner Reviews (fellow travelers) · BourbonStreet neighborhood

You are hungry visitor number
005969

E-mail Andre
[email protected]

Last updated September 24, 1999, after lunch.
© 1998-1999 Andre Fontenot. No shop paid for anything on this page. Several of them should be ashamed.
No photos. I had a camera at Tee-Roy's once and got gravy on it.